Wall Street’s Warning Amid the AI Race

Within the tech world, today’s giants can become tomorrow’s forgotten names. BlackBerry and Nokia learned this the hard way, and now some Wall Street analysts fear that Apple, the world’s most valuable company, might be heading toward a similar moment if it doesn’t accelerate its investment in artificial intelligence (AI).


From Absolute Leaders to Warning Tales

In the mid-2000s, BlackBerry dominated the smartphone market. Its iconic QWERTY keyboard, instant email reception, and reputation as an essential tool for professionals pushed the company’s stock above $140 per share in 2008. However, their reluctance to adapt and the advent of Apple’s iPhone changed the landscape overnight. A few years later, BlackBerry’s value plummeted by over 97%.

Similarly, Nokia was synonymous with mobile phones, holding more than 40% of the global market share and being associated with durability and reliability. But their late entry into touchscreens, combined with a flawed strategy around the Symbian OS and a failed partnership with Microsoft, led to their reign evaporating. In 2013, Nokia sold its mobile division to Microsoft, closing a chapter that seemed unimaginable a decade earlier.

The common denominator in both cases was the same: an inability to swiftly adapt to technological disruption. Past success became a burden that prevented timely radical decisions.


A Warning to Apple: A “BlackBerry or Nokia Moment” in the AI Era

In a recent note, Dan Ives, a tech analyst at Wedbush Securities and usually optimistic about Apple, took a different tone. He warns that Cupertino could face its own “BlackBerry moment” if it doesn’t act quickly and decisively in the field of generative artificial intelligence.

Apple has 2.4 billion active iOS devices, including 1.5 billion iPhones—an unmatched user base in the industry. Yet, while competitors like Microsoft, Google, Meta, Amazon, and even startups like OpenAI lead innovation in AI, Apple appears overly cautious.

Ives describes the situation vividly: “Apple is sitting on a park bench drinking lemonade, watching from the sidelines instead of competing.”


Three Key Steps to Avoid Decline

The analyst suggests three strategic moves he believes are crucial for Apple to prevent repeating BlackBerry or Nokia’s mistakes:

  1. Acquire Perplexity AI
    This startup has built an AI-native search engine capable of delivering precise, contextual answers. Ives sees it as an ideal candidate to revitalize Siri, which has seen little progress in recent years. He estimates that a purchase exceeding $30 billion would be “cheap” compared to the revenue potential from new AI-driven services. Although Perplexity has denied talks with Apple, the recommendation underscores the importance of integrating top-tier external capabilities.

  2. Hire External AI Talent
    Ives believes Apple’s innovation has stagnated and that a change in leadership in key areas is needed. He compared recent product launches to “watching repeats of Back to the Future” and suggested bringing in experienced AI leaders from outside, something Apple has historically done cautiously.

  3. Bet on Google’s Gemini
    Despite potential regulatory hurdles, Ives considers deep integration of Google’s Gemini chatbot within the iPhone ecosystem a strategic move. He states that “OpenAI is not a viable long-term partner” and warns that the window for decision-making is closing.


Why the BlackBerry and Nokia Comparisons are Relevant Now

BlackBerry’s main business—secure email and physical keyboard—prevented it from accepting that the future was touchscreen and app-driven. Nokia, meanwhile, relied heavily on its hardware dominance and underestimated the importance of a robust software ecosystem.

Apple, while still leading in design, hardware integration, and services, could make a similar mistake if it underestimates the impact of generative AI on user experience. The risk isn’t that iPhones will vanish overnight, but that they could lose relevance compared to more intelligent, integrated, and personalized devices and platforms.


Competitive Pressure

  • Microsoft has integrated Copilot across Windows, Office, and invested billions in OpenAI.
  • Google is pushing Gemini as the core of its AI strategy in Android, search, and productivity.
  • Meta is developing open models like LLaMA for social media and other products.
  • Amazon advances with Alexa and generative models in AWS for enterprises.

While Apple has indicated some AI work—like advanced photo editing and transcription features—it has yet to unveil a comprehensive plan.


The Role of Siri and User Experience

Launched in 2011, Siri was among the first voice assistants in smartphones. Over the past decade, it has fallen behind competitors like Alexa, Google Assistant, and recent generative AI chatbots.

Reinventing Siri with advanced conversational capabilities, integrated throughout the Apple ecosystem, would not only strengthen the iPhone’s position but also open new revenue streams via premium AI services.


An Unmatched User Base, but Vulnerable

Apple’s closed and perfectly synchronized ecosystem gives it a clear edge. Users who own an iPhone, Apple Watch, and Mac are deeply integrated into its suite of services—iCloud, Apple Pay, and more.

The challenge is that if AI becomes the centerpiece of digital experiences and Apple doesn’t lead that shift, users might be tempted to explore more advanced options, even within Android or emerging platforms.


Lessons from the Past: Adapt or Perish

The stories of BlackBerry and Nokia demonstrate that disruptive innovation doesn’t wait. It’s not just about defending a dominant position but leading change—even if it means cannibalizing current products.

With a market capitalization of $3.33 trillion and a growth of 3,000% since 2008, Apple has the resources to make a decisive move in AI. The real question is whether it will act before its advantage erodes.


The Clock Is Ticking for Apple

The “BlackBerry or Nokia moment” acts more as a warning than an inevitable destiny. Apple has the potential and infrastructure to become a true leader in the new AI era but must shift from watching to acting. The race for AI isn’t a passing trend—it’s the new battleground that will determine the winners and losers of the next decade.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

  1. What does a “BlackBerry or Nokia moment” mean in tech?
    It refers to the rapid collapse of formerly dominant companies that failed to adapt to technological disruption, like how BlackBerry and Nokia faltered with the rise of iPhone and Android.

  2. Why do some analysts believe Apple is at risk?
    Because competitors like Microsoft, Google, and Meta are already embedding generative AI into their products, whereas Apple has yet to present a clear and ambitious plan in this space.

  3. How could Apple avoid this fate?
    By acquiring advanced AI technology (e.g., Perplexity AI), hiring specialized AI leaders, and forming strategic alliances to deeply embed AI into its ecosystem.

  4. What role does Siri play in this?
    Siri is seen as outdated compared to its competitors. Reinventing it with generative AI capabilities would be key to maintaining relevance for Apple devices.

Scroll to Top