US Judge Lets RAM Shortage Lawsuit Against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Proceed

DRAM memory modules next to a judge's gavel

US District Judge Noël Wise, of the US District Court for the Northern District of California, refused on November 14, 2026, to dismiss the class action lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron of conspiring to cut production of conventional DRAM memory since October 2022. The ruling does not find anyone guilty: it only holds that the facts alleged by the plaintiffs are plausible enough for the case to move forward. The three manufacturers have until December 7 to respond to the complaint.

The RAM shortage lawsuit in 30 seconds

  • What was decided: the judge denies Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron’s motion to dismiss the case Garciaguirre v. Samsung (26-cv-06345).
  • What’s alleged: coordinated DRAM cuts since 2022, a joint pivot to HBM memory for AI, and a near-simultaneous exit from DDR4 in 2025.
  • How much: the plaintiffs claim conventional DRAM prices rose around 697% in 18 months; this is an allegation, not a proven fact.
  • Next steps: the companies’ response is due before December 7, 2026, and the first case management conference is set for January 12, 2027.

The plaintiffs are seventeen consumers and small businesses from five states (California, Florida, Minnesota, New York and Wisconsin). They invoke Section 1 of the Sherman Act, the United States’ main antitrust law, along with those states’ competition and consumer protection rules. On the other side are Samsung Electronics and its subsidiary Samsung Semiconductor, SK Hynix America and Micron Technology, described in the order as the oligopoly that dominates DRAM. It’s important to stress the stage the case is at: in a motion to dismiss, the court takes the facts alleged in the complaint as true and only checks whether, if true, they would describe a violation. The companies have not yet had to rebut them with evidence.

What the plaintiffs claim

According to the complaint, the three manufacturers began cutting conventional DRAM production in late 2022. SK Hynix and Micron announced their cuts about three weeks apart, and Samsung followed roughly four and a half months later. From there, still according to the plaintiffs, all three shifted capacity toward the high-bandwidth memory (HBM) that AI accelerators require, locking in long-term supply commitments, and slowed or delayed new factories.

The complaint adds other parallel moves: all three manufacturers announcing the end of DDR4 production between April and June 2025, Micron shutting down its consumer brand Crucial in December 2025, and the introduction, in January 2026, of very similar practices to screen which customers they sell to. The result, again according to the plaintiffs, was a roughly 697% rise in conventional DRAM prices over eighteen months. They also point back to the 1998-2002 DRAM cartel, which ended in criminal convictions in the United States.

The memory shortage is real, and it has hit PC makers, module makers, and server buyers alike: graphics card prices alone have jumped 35% in just three months as memory runs short, and TeamGroup, for one, expects the worst to last until mid-2027. What the trial will have to clarify is whether that shortage was the result of independent decisions amid the AI boom, as the companies argue, or of an agreement among them.

Why this time is different from 2018

The companies sought dismissal by leaning on a precedent that had favored them: the case known as DRAM II, in which the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of a similar lawsuit against the same manufacturers over supply restrictions from 2016 to 2018. Judge Wise concludes that the new case is not a repeat of that one.

The order finds that the plaintiffs adequately describe three parallel behaviors: the initial cuts, the joint pivot to HBM, and the DDR4 exit. It did not credit the claims about DDR3, since Micron kept making it. For a parallel pattern to look suspicious, US case law also requires so-called «plus factors» — signs that it isn’t simple imitation. The judge gives weight to four: the shift to HBM together with the Crucial shutdown and the slowdown in new factories, the DDR4 exit, the nearly identical customer-screening practices, and the three companies’ cartel history.

Not everything favors the plaintiffs. The order dismisses the executives’ statements to investors, which it considers consistent with unilateral decisions, and it does not rely on industry conference meetings, given what was already said in DRAM II. Nor does it give weight to the market structure, since the oligopoly existed in both cases. No single element is decisive on its own, but taken together, the judge finds that the conduct goes beyond simply watching one another, comparing it to «hawks flying in formation». She also notes that, at this stage, the Ninth Circuit does not require plaintiffs to rule out that the companies acted independently.

What happens now, and who it affects

Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron must file their response before December 7, 2026. The judge also agreed, with no opposition from the plaintiffs, to push back the initial deadlines: the first case management conference is set for January 12, 2027, at 9:00 a.m. From there comes the discovery phase, in which the plaintiffs can request internal documents and communications, and later the decision on whether to certify the lawsuit as a class action.

The case is limited to US buyers and to conventional DRAM, not HBM. For a European customer, a company refreshing its laptops, or a supplier expanding servers, nothing changes in the short term: prices are still set by the market, and the order does not force the manufacturers to produce more or cut prices. What matters is that, for the first time in this crisis, a court has found enough grounds to examine whether something more than AI demand was behind the memory price surge. The companies can still defend themselves on the merits, and none of the allegations has been proven.

Frequently asked questions

Have Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron been found guilty?

No. The judge has only refused to dismiss the lawsuit because the alleged facts are plausible; guilt will have to be proven during the proceedings.

What are they accused of?

Of conspiring since October 2022 to cut conventional DRAM production, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act and the laws of five states.

How much has memory gone up in price, according to the lawsuit?

The plaintiffs cite a 697% increase over eighteen months for conventional DRAM. That figure comes from the complaint and has not been verified by the court.

What are the key upcoming dates?

The companies must respond before December 7, 2026, and the first case management conference is on January 12, 2027.

Source: US District Court for the Northern District of California (order ECF 68, case 26-cv-06345)

This article is also available in Spanish: «Una jueza de EE. UU. mantiene la demanda por la escasez de RAM», on revistacloud.com.

Scroll to Top